Earl Grey with Lemon – A Citrusy Twist on the Classic Tea You Need to Try

Earl Grey with Lemon is a fresh, zesty upgrade to a classic tea. At Recipes of Kitchen – The Gluten-Free Sweet Kitchen, I love simple twists that bring big flavor—and this one does exactly that. And this citrusy combo is a favorite for both sipping and baking.

In this guide, we’ll cover why it works so well, whether to add milk or lemon, how to brew it right, and a few creative ways to enjoy it in drinks and desserts.

The Basics – What Is Earl Grey Tea?

The Origins of Earl Grey Tea

Earl Grey tea has a long-standing reputation as a classy, slightly mysterious tea. It’s named after Charles Grey, the British Prime Minister in the 1830s. The tea blend was likely created to imitate expensive Chinese teas by adding bergamot oil—a citrus flavor extracted from a type of orange.

What Makes Earl Grey Tea Unique?

Unlike standard black tea, Earl Grey offers a distinct floral and citrusy aroma.. The base is typically Assam, Darjeeling, or Ceylon tea, and it’s infused with the distinctive essence of bergamot. That flavor is what makes it work so well with lemon.

Adding a splash of lemon to Earl Grey amplifies its natural citrus notes, creating a cleaner, brighter, and more refreshing flavor.

Understanding the Role of Bergamot Oil

Bergamot oil is the signature ingredient that gives Earl Grey its distinctive flavor.. It’s what gives the tea its sharp, fragrant quality. Since lemon shares many of the same flavor compounds, the combination feels natural—not overpowering.

When prepared properly, Earl Grey with lemon highlights the tea’s natural brightness and smooths out any bitterness from the black tea leaves.

Print

Why Lemon Works So Well with Earl Grey

The Flavor Chemistry: Citrus + Citrus

The magic behind Earl Grey with lemon lies in flavor chemistry. Earl Grey is infused with bergamot oil, a citrus extract that shares flavor notes with lemon. When you add lemon juice or a thin slice of lemon to your tea, it enhances the bergamot rather than clashing with it. The result? A cleaner, brighter sip with a subtle tang that balances the black tea’s natural astringency.

How Lemon Enhances Tea’s Aroma

Lemon doesn’t just affect the taste—it amplifies the aroma of your Earl Grey. The steam from the cup releases more fragrant citrus oils into the air, making the tea smell more vibrant and inviting. That first sip of Earl Grey with lemon hits both the nose and the palate with a refreshing, invigorating feel.

Classic vs. Modern Pairings with Earl Grey

Traditionally, Earl Grey is enjoyed with a splash of milk or a drizzle of honey, particularly in classic British tea service. But modern drinkers are leaning toward lighter, more citrus-forward blends. Adding lemon to Earl Grey not only suits vegan and dairy-free diets—it also appeals to those who enjoy sharper, less creamy profiles.

This twist brings a new dimension to a classic brew, making Earl Grey with lemon perfect for morning refreshment, a midday energy boost, or even an iced summer drink.

Is Earl Grey Good with Lemon?

Taste Profile When Lemon Is Added

Yes—Earl Grey with lemon is not only good, it’s outstanding when done right. The lemon enhances the tea’s citrus undertones, turning it into a refreshing, bright, and slightly tangy drink. The bergamot oil already gives Earl Grey its distinct character, and lemon complements that with an extra lift, cutting bitterness and intensifying the aroma.

It’s especially enjoyable for those who prefer their tea without milk or want a lighter, cleaner finish.

Who Will Love Earl Grey with Lemon?

This citrus-forward twist on the classic tea is perfect for:

• Lemon lovers who enjoy tangy drinks
• Iced tea fans looking for bold flavor
• Milk-free tea drinkers
• Afternoon tea hosts who want something elegant and unexpected

Whether you’re a tea connoisseur or a casual sipper, Earl Grey with lemon offers a simple upgrade with gourmet results.

Pros and Cons of Adding Lemon

Pros	Cons
Brightens and lifts the flavor	Can curdle milk (if added too)
Enhances the citrus notes	Too much lemon can overpower
Great in hot or iced tea	May not pair well with sweeteners

Pro Tip: Always add lemon after brewing to preserve antioxidants and prevent bitterness.

Earl Grey with Lemon or Milk – What’s Better?

Comparing Flavor Profiles

• Earl Grey with milk creates a smooth, mellow, creamy flavor that balances the astringency of black tea.
• Earl Grey with lemon delivers a sharp, zesty profile with brightness and floral complexity.

The better option depends on your mood. Want cozy and comforting? Go with milk. Craving clean and crisp? Lemon is your best bet.

Tea Traditions: British vs. Continental

In British tea culture, milk is often the default pairing for black teas—including Earl Grey. But on the European continent, it’s common to enjoy black tea with a slice of lemon, especially in Eastern Europe and Mediterranean countries.

Today, many tea lovers embrace both approaches, alternating based on time of day or season.

When to Use Lemon vs. When to Use Milk

Use Lemon When…	Use Milk When…
Serving iced Earl Grey	Serving hot Earl Grey in winter
You want a light, detox-style tea	You want a full-bodied, rich cup
You’re avoiding dairy or going vegan	You’re making a creamy tea latte

Ultimately, there’s no wrong choice. Earl Grey with lemon just happens to be the more refreshing, versatile option—especially for summer or post-meal sipping.

How to Make Earl Grey Tea with Lemon

Brewing the Perfect Cup of Earl Grey

Start with high-quality Earl Grey loose leaf or a strong tea bag. For the best flavor:

• Use 1 tsp loose tea or 1 tea bag per 8 oz of water
• Boil water to 200–212°F (just below boiling)
• Steep for 3–5 minutes for optimal flavor strength

Strong tea balances lemon’s acidity. Avoid over-steeping—it can turn bitter.

When and How to Add Lemon (Juice vs. Slice)

After steeping, add lemon:

• Lemon slice: Adds aroma, flavor, and aesthetic appeal
• Lemon juice: Adds a brighter, more intense citrus hit

If you’re using lemon juice, start with ½ teaspoon, taste, and adjust as needed. For a more subtle infusion, drop in a thin lemon round and let it steep for 1–2 minutes.

Never boil lemon with tea—it can dull the flavor and kill the fresh zest.

Optional Sweeteners: Honey, Sugar, or None?

Whether or not to sweeten your Earl Grey with lemon depends on your preference:

• Honey adds floral notes and soothes the throat
• Brown sugar gives it a caramel twist
• No sweetener lets the tea and lemon shine

Flavor Pairings – What Goes Well with Earl Grey and Lemon?

Snacks and Bakes That Match the Blend

Earl Grey with lemon pairs beautifully with:

• Shortbread cookies (especially lemon or vanilla infused)
• Madeleines, scones, and light pastries
• Citrus muffins or lemon drizzle cake

The bright acidity of lemon cuts through buttery treats, refreshing the palate with every sip.

Herbs, Spices & Floral Additions

Want to get creative? Try adding:

• Fresh mint – adds cooling balance
• Cinnamon or clove – gives it warmth in winter
• Lavender or rose petals – adds floral elegance

These herbs and florals complement the bergamot-lemon combo without overwhelming it.

Citrus Companions: Orange, Grapefruit, Lime?

You’re not limited to lemon. Try blending Earl Grey with:

• Orange peel or juice for extra sweetness
• Grapefruit for bitterness and depth
• Lime for a sharp, tangy finish

Each adds a unique twist while keeping the citrus theme consistent.

Creative Recipes Using Earl Grey and Lemon

Iced Earl Grey Lemonade

This summer favorite blends tea with citrus for a refreshing twist. Here’s how to make it:

Ingredients:

• 2 cups brewed, cooled Earl Grey
• 1 cup fresh lemonade
• Ice + lemon slices
• Optional: splash of sparkling water

Instructions:

1. Brew a strong batch of Earl Grey and chill.
2. Mix 2 parts tea with 1 part lemonade.
3. Serve over ice with lemon slices or mint.

This is an easy way to enjoy Earl Grey with lemon chilled—perfect for warm afternoons or brunch drinks.

Earl Grey Lemon Mocktail or Cocktail

For a more elevated drink:

• Brew Earl Grey and let it cool
• Add lemon juice, simple syrup, and a splash of ginger beer
• Garnish with a lemon twist and a sprig of rosemary

For cocktails, add vodka, gin, or even bourbon for a smoky-citrus edge.

Baking with Earl Grey and Lemon

You can also bake with this combo:

• Earl Grey lemon cookies – add crushed tea leaves and zest
• Lemon loaf with Earl Grey glaze – steep tea in milk for your icing
• Infused syrup – make a bergamot-lemon sugar drizzle for cakes

The combo of floral and citrus gives a sophisticated flair to classic bakes.

Health Benefits of Earl Grey with Lemon

Antioxidants in Black Tea and Lemon

Earl Grey with lemon is more than delicious—it’s a smart health choice. Black tea is packed with powerful antioxidants, including theaflavins and catechins. Adding lemon increases the body’s ability to absorb those compounds thanks to vitamin C.

The result? A powerful cup that supports your cells while satisfying your taste buds.

Digestive and Immune System Support

Lemon is known to:

• Aid digestion
• Detoxify the liver
• Boost the immune system with natural vitamin C

Pair that with the moderate caffeine in Earl Grey, and you’ve got a gentle stimulant that can replace coffee and improve gut health.

Caffeine Considerations with Lemon Tea

Earl Grey contains moderate caffeine, making it a good mid-morning or early afternoon drink. Adding lemon doesn’t increase caffeine but enhances alertness thanks to the refreshing flavor and scent.

If you’re caffeine-sensitive, opt for a decaf version—you’ll still get all the lemony brightness with less stimulation.

Don’t miss Irresistibly Sweet Cornbread Cookies with Honey Glaze to extend freshness without flavor loss.

Tips, Variations & Storage

Cold Brew Earl Grey with Lemon

Cold brewing is an excellent way to enjoy Earl Grey with lemon without bitterness. Just:

• Add 2 tablespoons loose Earl Grey tea to 1 liter of cold water
• Let steep in the fridge for 8–12 hours
• Strain, then add fresh lemon juice or slices before serving

This slow infusion method makes a smooth, mellow drink perfect for hot days.

Lemon Peel vs. Lemon Juice – Which Is Better?

Both have different strengths:

Form	Flavor Profile	Best Use
Lemon Juice	Sharp, tangy, fresh	Hot tea, lemonade mix
Lemon Peel	Aromatic, lightly bitter	Infused syrup, baking

For drinks, lemon juice offers immediate brightness. For slow infusions or desserts, use lemon peel or zest to extract oils and aroma gradually.

How to Store Leftover Tea Without Losing Flavor

• Keep brewed Earl Grey with lemon in a glass jar with a lid
• Store in the fridge up to 3 days
• Avoid plastic containers—they absorb citrus oils
• Reheat gently or enjoy iced with honey and fresh lemon added before serving

FAQ – Earl Grey with Lemon